by Khor » Tue Jan 31, 2012 7:21 pm
The Thing (2011).
Perfect example of where the Uncanny Valley effect should apply. The Carpenter's Thing was weird, its transformations unpractical, the human parts it mimicked looked so fake, it moved like a wooden puppet, but those were actually qualities, things that made it horrific.
The new one feels like it knows how to use a face, understands human expressions, mimics them perfectly, while the old one was so awkward, even when it was hidden under a human appearance. To me that's what made it really look alien, that creature trying to blend in but eventually so obviously failing. The fact that the SFX weren't so perfect back then made it look like it didn't know how to deal with the situation. It copied faces but didn't know what to do with those, at least that's the feeling I got back then. With the layer of nice CGI, I wonder why it even bothers to attack...
The movie does a decent job at being a prequel, even it I have a few beefs with it, but well, the Carpenter's one is far from perfect. I mean, the main character fries a computer because it won at chess, the guy's straight off a Frank Miller comic, they carry guns and flamethrowers (is that a standard equipment in Antarctic research stations ?)...
But when you follow up a movie like that, you have to up the ante a bit. That one just does its best not to copy its past sequel, which is good enough I guess. It perfectly ties in where it has to, and explores new situations here and there...
The Eagles are the soundtrack accompaniment to contemporary Sisyphus riding two escalators up and down a hill with a small rock in his hand for eternity.